Damaged Goods

Let’s talk about sex. Ba-by.

My Kindle essay, “The Valley of Achor,” is about obsession, infatuation, and love.  It is about sex and faith and God and mercy and redemption.  I have thought so much about these things ever since I prayed at 18 that whatever was causing my period to be two weeks late would go away.  It did.  I don’t know if I was pregnant.  I suspect that I was and that I miscarried, based on the number of times I’ve miscarried since that personal crisis in college.

Now, I am happily married, to a different man than the one I dated in college.  That man’s shadow has followed me, sometimes more often than other times.  We dated on and off for a year and a half, and I gave myself to him in many ways.  I would have married him, if he had asked.  Needless to say, he left a major imprint on my life.

A while back, Matt Walsh, a popular and sometimes controversial blogger, posted a blog on abstinence.  I agree with much of what he has to say, but I take issue with two things: his tone, and this sentiment:

“…Are you satisfied that what you give to your spouse is now secondhand?  If they tell you they feel happy or neutral about the fact that they gave themselves to someone other than their spouse, you’re dealing with someone in a very dysfunctional marriage. Any honest person in a healthy relationship would tell you they’d erase those moments from their lives if they could. …That means millions have had to look at their spouse and say — probably silently in their own heads, deep in their subconscious — ‘I have nothing new to give to you.’  It’s a tragedy, really. It’s a shame. You deal with it and you move on, but ‘casual sex’ has taken its chunk and you’ll never get it back.” – Matt Walsh blog


When Brandon and I met, I was worried about revealing my past to him.  He was a Christian, the first believer I had seriously dated since becoming a Christian myself, and I worried that he might condemn me or reject me because I was “secondhand,” no longer a virgin, impure.  When the time came to discuss these things (and honestly, we pushed the topic to the front of the line way faster than we should have), there was no condemnation, because he had failed in this area, too.

Did these pre-marital relationships affect our relationship?  Absolutely.  Probably they still do, to some degree, the ripple effect of loving someone deeply and then losing them lasts for a long time.  However, Matt is missing a vital element of the message of the Cross. From Romans, “Therefore there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” and slightly later in the same chapter, “And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose.”

In all things.  The power of the Cross is not that we might strive for perfection and receive our reward based on how good we’ve been.  The power of the Cross is that we are free from the burden of perfection and made holy and pure through the redemptive love, grace, and mercy of Christ.  Not because of anything we’ve done, but only because of Christ.  Only because of the Father’s love.  Only because of the power of the Holy Spirit.

I don’t think I can regret for myself anymore the decisions I made to have sex before I married Brandon.  Maybe I regret how long I spent seeking after a person who no longer loved me back.  But that crisis in my life drove me to my knees, it woke me up to the realities of my imperfection and my lack of control, it released me from the grip of “do good things” and delivered me into the garden of “I have loved you with an everlasting love, I have drawn you with unfailing kindness.”  Not condemnation.  How can I live in regret when God has delivered me into that garden?

Teach your children abstinence. Not because they will carry regret and shame with them the rest of their lives if they don’t.  Not because they will be “damaged goods” otherwise, “secondhand” to the spouse they marry.  Not because they might have a baby out of wedlock or get a sexually transmitted disease.  Those are not good reasons.  They are not true reasons.  They are symptoms of a deeper emptiness or injury and they ignore redemption.

Teach your children abstinence because purity is a worthy pursuit, and abstinence is one facet of purity.  But it isn’t the only one: purity manifests itself in our thoughts, our words, and our deeds.  It might please God that you are seeking purity, but that isn’t why he loves you.


Attacking sex as the only manifestation of purity or impurity does what we Christians have done for centuries – identified one sin to place under a spotlight as worthy of condemnation.  Teach your children all of the worthy pursuits – love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, gentleness, and self-control (that’s where abstinence fits in this list).  And when they fall — because they will, in some way, fall — be prepared to extend the same grace and mercy Jesus Christ extends to you, every single day of your broken and imperfect life.

“Jesus straightened up and asked her, ‘Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?’ ‘No one, sir,’ she said. ‘Then neither do I condemn you,’ Jesus declared. ‘Go now and leave your life of sin.'” – John 8:10-11

Published by Sarah M. Wells

Sarah M. Wells is the author of The Family Bible Devotional: Stories from the Gospels to Help Kids and Parents Love God and Love Others (2022), American Honey: A Field Guide to Resisting Temptation (2021), Between the Heron and the Moss (2020), The Family Bible Devotional: Stories from the Bible to Help Kids and Parents Engage and Love Scripture (2018), Pruning Burning Bushes (2012), and a chapbook of poems, Acquiesce, winner of the 2008 Starting Gate Award through Finishing Line Press (2009). Sarah's work has been honored with four Pushcart Prize nominations, and her essays have appeared in the notable essays list in the Best American Essays 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2017, and 2018. Sarah is the recipient of a 2018 Individual Excellence Award from the Ohio Arts Council. She resides in Ashland, Ohio with her husband and three children.

3 thoughts on “Damaged Goods

  1. Wonderful insights, Sarah. We all need forgiveness over and over. And when we find it at the foot of the Cross, we need to be willing to forgive ourselves and others. “As far as the east is from the west, so far has he removed our transgressions from us . . .”


  2. I think this is my favorite post of yours, Sarah. So brave, so honest, and so, so needed. I'm filing it away for myself, for my girls, for anyone who needs this wonderfully truthful reminder. Thank you for writing it.


  3. Oh how I love this. I too have been wrestling with sex and sexuality and how in the world to teach purity to my children. I read that post by Matt Walsh a few days ago, before reading what you had written and I was almost enraged by his short sighted comments about abstinence. Secondhand? Nothing new to give? Really? It was just plain offensive. I should write him. This blog post should be shared with him. Your insight was spot on about Christ. About purity. Spot on. Thank you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: